29 Aug

Measuring Success

Posted in DIY MFA, Goals, Process

One topic that we’ll come back to many times in the DIY MFA is this idea of measuring success.  Unlike a typical MFA, where you can measure your success through grades, a diploma or post-graduation opportunities, the DIY MFA is, by definition, un-measurable since different people would consider different things to be “success.”

This brings me to a concept that I first learned about in Psychology 101 in college: Operational Definition.  In psychology, you’re usually dealing with outcome variables that are very abstract and difficult to measure.  Stress.  Anger.  Fear.  Part of the reason these variables are so hard to measure is because different people experience them in different ways.  It’s up to the psychologist to find another variable–one that’s concrete and easy to measure–to approximate the variable we really care about.

For instance, you can’t ask a bunny if it’s hungry because it’s a bunny and it doesn’t speak English.  You can, however, count how many carrots it eats in a given time period.  More carrots = more hungry.

Similarly, while you can ask human subjects if they were hungry (say on a 1-10 scale), you could run into problems.  First: what might be a 4 on the scale for one person might be a 2 on a hunger scale for someone else.  Second: people sometimes lie.  If, however, you give everyone the same “snack” during the experiment and then secretly measure how much food is left at the end, you can have a reasonable indicator of who was hungry and who was not.  When you spread that data over a large sample, you can account for individual discrepancies and your concrete measure (weight of leftover snack) actually becomes a very good indicator for your abstract variable (hunger).

OK, I didn’t mean to get overly technical, but there’s a reason I’m going into all this detail.  The fact is, DIY MFA success is an abstract outcome variable, making it difficult to measure.  If we set smaller, concrete goals, on the other hand, we can have a pretty good indication of whether we’ve succeeded or not.  As we work on putting together our DIY MFA individualized programs, remind yourself to keep your goals concrete.

Why is it so important that goals be concrete?

  1. Abstract goals are hard to measure.  Telling yourself “I’m going to become a better writer” is all well and good, but how will you know when you get there?  Instead, you could try: “I’ll write and edit three stories in the next three months” or “I’ll submit one story to 10 literary magazines.”  Then with a simple checklist you’ll know if you’ve succeeded or not.
  2. Vague goals are scary.  OK, maybe I’m more of a wimp than most people but nothing freaks me out more than a vague goal.  If the goal is too amorphous, it’s easy to get overwhelmed, but if the goal is concrete, it automatically becomes more doable.  “Write a novel someday” sounds scary.  But “write five pages a day”?  Well, I know I can write 5 pages today and I guess I could do it tomorrow too and probably the next day… and you get the idea.
  3. Checking things off the list feels good.  If you’re measuring success with small, concrete goals, it means you get to check things off the list more often than if you look at it as just one vague goal.  If you look at success as one big goal, then that’s only one thing you get to check off the list but think of how many checks you’d get if you broke down that goal into small, concrete goals.
  4. Concrete goals make it easier to track your progress.  Say your goal is to write a novel, but you break it down to 5 pages per day, six days per week.  That means, in 8-10 weeks you should be pretty close to finishing the whole thing.  If you stick to your weekly goals, you should have a good measure of how close you are to finishing your progress.

During DIY MFA month, I want to accomplish the following abstract goals (broken down into concrete goals):

  • Finish my novel (8 chapters left – 2 chapters or approx. 4000 words per week words for 4 weeks)
  • Read more (one book per week for 4 weeks)
  • Submit a short story (Submit A.H. to 5 markets per week for 4 weeks, total of 20 magazines)

What abstract goals can you break down into concrete goals for DIY MFA?


Comments on this post

  1. Merrilee says:

    Excellent. I'll think about my goals and get them up in the next few days.

    1. Kerryn Angell says:

      Oh eek! Some part of me knew this was coming but I'm very scared of setting expectations for myself. I know these are goals and not expectations and yet I am still trying to unravel the two. My goals will be simple. Like reading the class posts and participating in discussion.

      1. gabi says:

        Kerryn – Goal-setting scares the besneezes out of me too, which is why I'm all about small, manageable goals. Your goals of reading the posts and participating in discussion sound fantastic! Remember, it's always easier to add goals later on than to start with too many goals and then have to abandon a few en route. 🙂

        1. Shaddy says:

          I'm with Kerryn. I'm not a goal setter. Unfortunately, I've never been one and at my age don't see much hope for that happening in the future. Nevertheless, I'm going to work on coming up with some abstract and concrete goals even if it kills me…and it just might.

          Mostly, I am looking for some motivation and direction to get me writing with excitement again.

          Besides all that, I really want to hang out with iggi.

          1. Sonia says:

            I love this— I'm horrible at setting manageable goals for myself, and it always gets me into trouble! I pledge to write three pages and edit at least five pages of old work every day.

            1. Janice says:

              1. Finish draft 4 of my ms and tie up all research (revise roughly 8 pages a per day)

              2. Submit a short story to my favorite agent blog. (I’m really frightened, but have had the story written for a while)

              3. Read at least 2 fiction books per week.

              4. Read 1 book on the craft of writing over 2 week period – 2 over course of DIY MFA.

              5. Study grammar for at least one hour every day.

Iggi & Gabi - All rights reserved © 2010-2011

I am a HowJoyful Design by Joy Kelley